Close this search box.

Sibling Rivalry Over Power of Attorney: Resolving Friction

Picture of Stevenson Law Office

Stevenson Law Office

Unpacking the Family Feud: Understanding Sibling Rivalry Over Power of Attorney

Sibling rivalry over power of attorney can escalate into a complex legal struggle, jeopardizing family harmony and potentially resulting in protracted litigation. A power of attorney is a legal instrument that grants one person the authority to make decisions on behalf of another. When a family member is designated as an agent, this can sometimes lead to disagreements among siblings, who may question the motives or decisions of the appointed individual. At Stevenson Law Office, we recognize these scenarios require a delicate balance between legal expertise and emotional intelligence to navigate effectively.

The Legal Implications of Power of Attorney Disputes

The significance of a power of attorney extends far beyond the family dynamic; it is anchored in legal authority and responsibility. The law places considerable trust in the hands of the agent, which, naturally, other family members may contest based on concerns about capacity, undue influence, or breach of fiduciary duty. Our firm has seen how sibling rivalry over power of attorney can unfold, often necessitating a nuanced understanding of both statutory laws and case precedents in resolving disputes.

Navigating the Emotional and Legal Tangle

Combining family tensions with legal challenges can create a unique tangle of emotional and legal issues. We believe that successfully managing these cases requires a comprehensive approach, considering not only the legal standing of the power of attorney but also the underlying family dynamics. In addressing sibling rivalry over power of attorney disputes, our focus is to achieve resolutions that maintain as much family unity as possible, while ensuring that our clients’ rights and the intentions of the person who granted the power of attorney are upheld.

Identifying the Root Causes of Sibling Rivalry Over Power of Attorney

At our Stevenson Law Office, we’ve found that a major source of sibling rivalry over power of attorney often stems from deep-rooted and underlying issues that are not necessarily related to the legal document itself. Among widely observed causes are:

  • Perceived inequality: One sibling may feel the other wields an unfair degree of power, sparking feelings of resentment.
  • Lack of communication: Often, a well-informed discussion can prevent escalating misunderstandings or misconceptions about the power of attorney terms.
  • Differing views on care for a family member: Disagreements on the best approach to care can fuel conflicts, especially when it concerns a parent’s wellbeing or estate.

Understanding these core issues can help in working towards a resolution.

Legal Options and Remedies in Power of Attorney Disagreements

In cases of disputes, the law provides several avenues and resources for resolution that we can guide you through. Mediation is one such option where a neutral third party helps facilitate a conversation aimed at reaching an agreement. On the other hand, litigation is a more formal legal process, requiring a judge to make a binding decision. This route may be more relevant in cases of deep-rooted or extended conflict.

Protecting Your Rights and Inheritance in the Throes of Sibling Conflict

Just because there is sibling rivalry over power of attorney, it doesn’t mean you should not protect your rights and inheritance. We can assist in ensuring you’re treated fairly in the midst of a power of attorney dispute, by addressing your legal rights and interests.

Regular consultation with a trusted attorney is a proactive measure to safeguard your share of the estate; it prevents potential misuse of power or unsanctioned transactions. We also advocate for regular family meetings to update all siblings on estate matters, fostering an environment of transparency. This can significantly help in reducing misunderstanding and potential areas of dispute.

Remember that navigating these sensitive matters involves more than just the legalities; it also calls for tact and empathy in dealing with familial relationships. As professionals, we understand this balance and ensure our clients are guided every step of the way.

Did you know that adding a “no-contest” clause to your will can dissuade potential challenges by imposing a penalty for contesting the terms?

“No-contest” clauses aim to preserve estate plans by threatening to limit or eliminate the share of a beneficiary who disputes the will or power of attorney arrangements, often reducing the likelihood of legal battles among heirs.

Strategies for Resolving Sibling Rivalry Over Power of Attorney

At Stevenson Law Office, we understand that navigating the complexities of trust estate matters can be both challenging and emotional, particularly when sibling rivalry over power of attorney comes into play. To mitigate conflict, we advocate for open communication and transparency. It’s crucial to engage all siblings in conversations about the responsibilities and implications of power of attorney. By working together to establish trust and clarity, family members can often find common ground and avoid escalation to legal disputes.

The Role of Professional Estate and Trust Administration

Seeking the assistance of professional estate and trust administration can be an effective way to minimize sibling rivalry over power of attorney. Our skilled team can provide neutral guidance and facilitate the distribution of responsibilities in a manner that respects the family dynamic and the wishes of the person who granted the power of attorney. We work diligently to ensure that all parties understand their roles and the legal parameters within which they must operate, thus reducing the potential for conflict.

Looking Beyond the Dispute: Fostering Family Harmony

At the heart of our practice is the belief that family harmony should be preserved, where possible, beyond the resolution of power of attorney disputes. We understand the value and long-term benefits of maintaining strong family relationships. Our goal is to counsel families through the legal intricacies of sibling rivalry over power of attorney while never losing sight of the enduring bonds that make up the family fabric. In doing so, we help families emerge from their disputes not only with a legal resolution but also with strategies for rebuilding and maintaining familial ties.


1. What does a power of attorney entail?

As Stevenson Law Office, we note that a power of attorney is a legal document that grants one person the authority to act on behalf of another person in specific legal or financial matters. These can become points of contention among siblings, especially when the principle becomes mentally incapacitated, and decisions about their health care, finances, or estate have to be made.

2. What are some common causes for power of attorney disputes among siblings?

Common causes for disputes may include perceived inequality, lack of communication, or differing views on the care for a family member. When siblings feel that they have not been treated equally in the granting of power of attorney, or if the one holding it fails to communicate effectively, it could lead to conflicts. Family dynamics can make these disputes complex and stressful, necessitating the need for legal counsel and guidance.

3. What legal options are available in power of attorney disagreements?

We typically recommend mediation or litigation, depending on the specifics of the case. Mediation involves a neutral third party who helps the siblings navigate their dispute and arrive at a mutually agreeable solution. However, if the dispute is severe or if mediation fails, it might be necessary to seek a court intervention.

4. Can a professional administrator ease the sibling rivalry over power of attorney?

Yes, a professional administrator can help mitigate and navigate sibling rivalry over power of attorney by ensuring correct and legal procedures are followed throughout the process. By staying neutral and focusing solely on the best interest of the incapacitated parent or relative, professionals can help avoid disputes and facilitate the process of continuity in affairs.

5. How can family harmony be maintained amidst a power of attorney dispute?

While it can be challenging, it is imperative to maintain familial relationships amidst such disputes. Effective communication, understanding, and respect, coupled with professional guidance, can help preserve family bonds. After the resolution of any legal issues, it is crucial to work on rebuilding trust and seeking common ground to ensure familial harmony.